Could list loads of pros and cons and research showing harm/no harm, effectiveness or otherwise and for every person who is for it you will find someone equally as strongly against it. However, at the end of the day it is up to you as parents to decide how to raise and discipline your children - within societal and legal parameters of acceptable behaviour.
This MOPS blog is not the place for a debate on smacking or lectures on how to raise your children.
The big decision (to use smacking as a form of discipline or not) is up to you.
Do your own research. Decide what works for your family.
That said, some of you wanted clarification/further info on the recent Victorian case (not NZ as I had typed in an earlier edit of this post) Karen A-D mentioned and the current legal stance on smacking in QLD so I will post that here.
Karen A-D referred to a recent Victorian (not NZ) case where a mum was questioned by police (but not charged) after her 9yo child mentioned at school that her mum smacked her with a wooden spoon. The police did say she could have been charged with 'assault with a weapon' according to current Victn law (it is up to the discretion of Vict Police whether to charge or not based on each case presented to them).
Note that teachers and some other professions have a mandatory reporting responsibility i.e they have to report suspected cases of neglect and abuse or can be held accountable for not reporting.
Laws differ slightly from state to state in Aust and in NZ it is currently illegal to smack a child.
"In New South Wales you're not allowed to hit children above the shoulders, you're not allowed to hit children in a way that leaves them marked or in injury and you're not allowed to hit children using any form of implement like a belt or a slipper."
See here or here for further info/media reports of the Victorian case and this smacking/legality debate.
This is the current legal stance on smacking as discipline in Queensland taken from http://legalstudiesqld.com.au/blog/category/crime-and-society/
No comments:
Post a Comment
Hi to all our MOPS Mums. We would love you to leave a comment.